discourse-coordinator
/discourse-coordinator
Koordynuje pakiet skilli do analizy dyskursu: kieruje między steel-manem, pytaniami sokratejskimi, analizą Toulmina, wykrywaniem błędów logicznych i nieuczciwej retoryki oraz facylitacją.
- Autor
- curiositech ↗
- Repozytorium
- windags-skills ↗
- Licencja
- Apache-2.0
- Ostatnia zmiana repozytorium
- 25.10.2026
Ocena i bezpieczeństwo
- Pliki w paczce
- 2
- Skrypty
- 0
- Komentarze HTML
- 0
- Adresy URL w SKILL.md
- 0
Brak sygnałów. Repozytorium zmienione 25.10.2026, bez odwołań do wycofanych modeli i API.
Apache-2.0, otwarta: można używać i zmieniać, z zachowaniem licencji i informacji o zmianach.
Co robi i kiedy
Koordynuje pakiet skilli do analizy dyskursu: kieruje między steel-manem, pytaniami sokratejskimi, analizą Toulmina, wykrywaniem błędów logicznych i nieuczciwej retoryki oraz facylitacją.
Oryginalny opis (EN)
Meta-skill that orchestrates the discourse skill suite: routes between steel-man-argument, socratic-questioning, toulmin-argument-analysis, logical-fallacy-detector, bad-faith-rhetoric-detector, discourse-elision-analyzer, forensic-speech-structure, and productive-discourse-facilitator. Use when analyzing conversations, facilitating discourse, or operating as a dialogue copilot. Maintains mode (silent analysis, coaching overlay, active facilitator) and decides which skills to invoke based on conversation dynamics.
Jak działa
- When to Use This Skill
- Four Cooperating Roles
- Three Operating Modes
- Routing Logic
- Orchestration Patterns
- State Tracking
- Sensitivity Settings
- Reference Files
Podgląd SKILL.md
--- name: discourse-coordinator description: "Meta-skill that orchestrates the discourse skill suite: routes between steel-man-argument, socratic-questioning, toulmin-argument-analysis, logical-fallacy-detector, bad-faith-rhetoric-detector, discourse-elision-analyzer, forensic-speech-structure, and productive-discourse-facilitator. Use when analyzing conversations, facilitating discourse, or operating as a dialogue copilot. Maintains mode (silent analysis, coaching overlay, active facilitator) and decides which skills to invoke based on conversation dynamics." metadata: version: '1.0' --- # Discourse Coordinator ## When to Use This Skill Use this skill when: - Operating as a **discourse copilot** across a multi-turn conversation - A user needs **holistic discourse support** rather than a single specific skill - **Analyzing** an ongoing or recorded conversation for quality, integrity, and dynamics - **Facilitating** a dialogue between parties with different positions - The user wants help **preparing** a persuasive speech, debate position, or written argument - Conflict level in a conversation is rising and you need to decide how to intervene - The user asks for "discourse analysis," "conversation coaching," or "dialogue support" Do NOT use this skill when the user has a narrow, single-skill request (e.g., "find fallacies in this paragraph" → use `logical-fallacy-detector` directly). --- ## Four Cooperating Roles The eight discourse skills are organized into four functional roles. This coordinator routes between them. ### Builder — Structures and Strengthens Arguments | Skill | Purpose | |---|---| | `steel-man-argument` | Construct the strongest possible version of any position | | `toulmin-argument-analysis` | Map claim → grounds → warrant → backing → qualifier → rebuttal | | `forensic-speech-structure` | Compose and structure a speech or written argument for delivery | ### Guide — Shapes the Process of Dialogue | Skill | Purpose | |---|---| | `socratic-questioning` | Drive inquiry-based exploration; surface assumptions | | `productive-discourse-facilitator` | Set norms, manage turns, propose phase transitions | ### Critic — Inspects Quality and Integrity | Skill | Purpose | |---|---| | `logical-fallacy-detector` | Identify formal and informal fallacies in reasoning | | `bad-faith-rhetoric-detector` | Flag manipulation, deflection, and bad-faith moves | | `discourse-elision-analyzer` | Detect what is conspicuously absent or avoided in a response | ### Coordinator — This Skill Routes between roles based on goal, mode, and conversation state. Tracks patterns across turns and manages mode transitions. --- ## Three Operating Modes ### Mode 1: Silent Analysis (Default) - Continuously evaluate each turn using **Critic** skills in the background - Surface only minimal indicators (e.g., a single-line flag) unless the user explicitly asks for detail - Track patterns across turns: escalation trajectory, repeated elisions, accumulating fallacy count - Never interrupt the flow of conversation; log internally and report on request **Activation**: Default on load. Also activated by phrases like "watch this conversation," "just observe," "monitor this." ### Mode 2: Coaching Overlay - Provide **private feedback to the user only** — the other party does not see this - Examples of coaching prompts: - "Your last turn dodged their core question about liability. Consider addressing it directly." - "Consider steelmanning their concern about X before pushing Y — it may reduce defensiveness." - "Their last three turns show a pattern: they've never engaged your cost argument. Flag it." - Suggest small, targeted interventions via **Guide** skills - Tone: supportive, non-judgmental, specific **Activation**: User phrases like "coach me," "give me feedback," "help me respond," "what should I say." ### Mode 3: Active Facilitator - All parties are **aware the agent is participating** as a third voice - Uses `productive-discourse-facilitator` to establish ground rules and manage turn structure - Proposes Structured Analytical Conversation (SAC) moves: restatements, clarifying questions, phase transitions - Calls out patterns that undermine dialogue **openly** (e.g., "I notice this question has gone unanswered three times") - Can introduce steelmanning rounds, inquiry phases, or synthesis prompts **Activation**: User phrases like "facilitate this," "be the moderator," "help us have this conversation," or explicit consent from all parties. --- ## Routing Logic Use these rules to decide which skill(s) to invoke for a given turn or request: | Situation | Primary Route | Secondary Check | |---|---|---| | User's goal is to **persuade** | Builder skills | Critic (quality check) | | User's goal is to **understand** | Guide skills | Critic (integrity check) | | User's goal is to **analyze/evaluate** | Critic skills | — | | **Conflict level rising** | Guide → `productive-discourse-facilitator` | Critic (monitoring) | | Long response follows short pointed question | `discourse-elision-analyzer` | `logical-fallacy-detector` | | Repeated non-engagement with a core point | `bad-faith-rhetoric-detector` | `discourse-elision-analyzer` | | User preparing to speak or write | Builder → Critic | — | | Emotional intensity high | `productive-discourse-facilitator` first | Builder after de-escalation | | Argument structure unclear | `toulmin-argument-analysis` | — | | User wants strongest form of opponent's view | `steel-man-argument` | — | | Formal speech or debate prep | `forensic-speech-structure` | `steel-man-argument` for rebuttal prep | For full decision trees, threshold definitions, and conflict-resolution between skills, see `references/routing-rules.md`. --- ## Orchestration Patterns ### Hot Topic Protocol (for active conflict) Use when two or more parties are in active disagreement with rising stakes. 1. **Phase 0 – Setup**: Facilitator asks each side for a brief 2–3 sentence position statement. Run `toulmin-argument-analysis` privately to map each side's structure. 2. **Phase 1 – Mutual Steelman**: `steel-man-argument` helps each side restate the other's position at its strongest. The originating party must confirm the restatement is accurate before proceeding. 3. **Phase 2 – Inquiry**: `socratic-questioning` drives a round of mutual questions. Each party asks one genuine question; the other must answer directly before asking theirs. 4. **Phase 3 – Integrity Check**: `logical-fallacy-detector` and `bad-faith-rhetoric-detector` scan the full conversation neutrally; findings shared with all parties. 5. **Phase 4 – Synthesis**: `productive-discourse-facilitator` guides toward identifying any shared ground, naming remaining disagreements precisely, and proposing next steps. ### Quick Analysis (for a single turn or response) Use when a user pastes a text and asks "what's wrong with this?" or "analyze this response." 1. Run `discourse-elision-analyzer` on the text — what is conspicuously absent? 2. Run `logical-fallacy-detector` on any arguments found 3. Summarize findings in 3–5 bullet points, ordered by significance ### Speech Prep Pipeline Use when a user is preparing a speech, essay, or structured argument. 1. `toulmin-argument-analysis` — structure raw ideas into claim/grounds/warrant/rebuttal scaffold 2. `logical-fallacy-detector` — clean up reasoning; remove or repair weak inferences 3. `forensic-speech-structure` — compose the speech with appropriate structure (introduction, body, conclusion, transitions) 4. `steel-man-argument` — anticipate the strongest counterarguments; build refutation section --- ## State Tracking Maintain this state across turns in a conversation: - **Conversation temperature**: calm → warm → heated → crisis - **Unanswered core questions**: running list; flag if a question goes unanswered for 3+ turns - **Pattern accumulation**: - Elision count (how many times key topics have been avoided) - Fallacy count (types and frequency) - Bad-faith pattern count (types and frequency) - **Mode**: current operating mode and what triggered any transitions - **Phase** (in Hot Topic Protocol): which phase the conversation is in Report state summary when asked or when escalating to a new mode. --- ## Sensitivity Settings Adjust behavior based on the declared or inferred context: **`relationship-mode`** (personal relationships, family, romantic partners): - Extra caution with labeling; avoid "bad faith" as a definitive label — use "pattern that may indicate..." - Validate emotional content before analytical content - Emphasize understanding over winning - Do not recommend confrontational moves **`professional-mode`** (workplace, business negotiations, academic debate): - More direct analysis; less emotional hedging - Name patterns clearly and specifically - Focus on argument structure and productive outcomes **`debate-prep-mode`** (competitive debate, formal argumentation): - Optimize for competitive strength; find every weakness in the opponent's case - Less concern for relationship preservation; prioritize logical rigor - Use `forensic-speech-structure` with competitive framing - Aggressive use of `steel-man-argument` to anticipate and pre-empt Set by user instruction or infer from context. Default: `professional-mode`. --- ## Reference Files - **`references/routing-rules.md`** — Detailed decision trees, threshold definitions, mode-transition procedures, skill-conflict resolution, priority ordering, full orchestration examples, and guidance on when to refer to human support. Load this file when handling complex routing decisions or unfamiliar orchestration scenarios.
Pliki w paczce (2)
- SKILL.md 10 KB
- references/routing-rules.md 21 KB
Wersje
W bazie nie ma innych skilli o nazwie discourse-coordinator.
Migawka bazy z 13.11.2026 · wersja paczki f3f98998a9c3 (skrót SHA-256 całej paczki)
Pobrania w ostatnich 30 dniach: 0 · ranking
Zgłoś problem z tym skillem: szkodliwa treść, błędny opis albo prośba autora o usunięcie.
Podobne skille
- 100productive-discourse-facilitator
Prowadzi empatyczne rozmowy i kieruje do konstruktywnego dialogu: deeskalacja, wzajemne zrozumienie, ustrukturyzowana dyskusja i rozwiązywanie konfliktów, z trybem dla par w procesie zdrowienia. - 96agentio-discourse
Obsługuje fora Discourse z poziomu agenta przez narzędzie wiersza poleceń agentio. - 100logical-fallacy-detector
Identyfikuje, nazywa i wyjaśnia błędy logiczne w argumentach i dyskursie, przy analizie argumentów, przygotowaniu do debaty i sprawdzaniu rozumowania.