Przejdź do treści
Biblioteka skilli
Projektowanie i UX · Przegląd i audyt

design-critic

/design-critic

Ocenia estetykę i punktuje projekt w 6 wymiarach, do krytyki UI, przeglądu projektu, oceny jakości wizualnej i sugestii remiksu.

Repozytorium
windags-skills ↗
Licencja
Apache-2.0
Ostatnia zmiana repozytorium
25.10.2026

Ocena i bezpieczeństwo

100/ 100Klasa: dobry
Format25 / 25
Frontmatter z nazwą i opisem, poprawna nazwa, opis do 1024 znaków, nazwa zgodna z folderem.
Odkrywalność25 / 25
Opis mówi, kiedy użyć skilla, ma sensowną długość i jest w 3. osobie.
Treść35 / 35
Co najmniej 150 słów i do 500 linii, nagłówki, listy kroków, przykłady albo kod.
Higiena15 / 15
Bez zaślepek typu TODO, bez ścieżek Windows, z licencją.
Ryzykobrak sygnałów w skanie
Pliki w paczce
5
Skrypty
0
Komentarze HTML
0
Adresy URL w SKILL.md
0
Przestarzałość

Brak sygnałów. Repozytorium zmienione 25.10.2026, bez odwołań do wycofanych modeli i API.

Licencja

Apache-2.0, otwarta: można używać i zmieniać, z zachowaniem licencji i informacji o zmianach.

Co robi i kiedy

Ocenia estetykę i punktuje projekt w 6 wymiarach, do krytyki UI, przeglądu projektu, oceny jakości wizualnej i sugestii remiksu.

Wyzwalacze z opisu

design critiqueaesthetic reviewUI assessmentvisual qualitydesign scoreremix this design
Oryginalny opis (EN)

Aesthetic assessment and design scoring across 6 dimensions. Use for UI critique, design review, visual quality assessment, remix suggestions. Activate on "design critique", "aesthetic review", "UI assessment", "visual quality", "design score", "remix this design". NOT for implementation (use frontend-developer), accessibility-only audits (use color-contrast-auditor), or brand identity creation.

Jak działa

  1. Decision Points
  2. Failure Modes
  3. Worked Examples
  4. Quality Gates
  5. NOT-FOR Boundaries
Sekcje z nagłówków SKILL.md, w oryginale · 171 linii, 961 słów
Podgląd SKILL.md
---
license: Apache-2.0
name: design-critic
description: Aesthetic assessment and design scoring across 6 dimensions. Use for UI critique, design review, visual quality assessment, remix suggestions. Activate on "design critique", "aesthetic review", "UI assessment", "visual quality", "design score", "remix this design". NOT for implementation (use frontend-developer), accessibility-only audits (use color-contrast-auditor), or brand identity creation.
allowed-tools: Read,Glob,Grep,WebFetch,WebSearch
category: Design & Creative
tags:
  - design-critique
  - feedback
  - review
  - aesthetics
  - ux
---

# Design Critic

AI partner with trained aesthetic taste for assessing, scoring, and remixing design implementations across 6 dimensions with weighted scoring.

## Decision Points

### Priority Triage by Overall Score
```
If score < 60:
  ├─ Start with Accessibility (20% weight, highest impact)
  ├─ Quick wins: contrast, focus states, touch targets
  └─ Then tackle Layout fundamentals

If score 60-79:
  ├─ Focus on Visual Hierarchy first
  │  ├─ Typography scaling issues?
  │  │  └─ Apply 1.25-1.5 ratio system
  │  └─ Layout weight imbalance?
  │     └─ Redistribute whitespace
  └─ Then address Color Harmony

If score 80+:
  ├─ Polish Modernity elements
  │  ├─ Current trend adoption without chasing
  │  └─ Micro-interaction improvements
  └─ Optimize Usability edge cases
```

### Dimension Scoring Logic
```
For each dimension:
If obvious failures present:
  ├─ Score 40-60 range
  └─ Flag as primary improvement target

If meets basic standards:
  ├─ Score 65-75 range
  └─ Look for polish opportunities

If exceeds expectations:
  ├─ Score 80+ range
  └─ Use as strength to highlight
```

### Trade-off Resolution
```
When Accessibility vs Aesthetics conflict:
├─ Always prioritize WCAG AA minimum
├─ Find aesthetic solution within constraints
└─ Document why aesthetic choice was rejected

When Modernity vs Usability conflict:
├─ Test with user mental models
├─ Choose familiar pattern if trend confuses
└─ Hybrid approach: familiar function, modern form
```

## Failure Modes

### "Aesthetic Tunnel Vision"
**Symptom**: Scoring visual appeal high while ignoring usability failures
**Diagnosis**: Not following accessibility-first assessment order
**Fix**: Always run WCAG contrast checker before aesthetic scoring
**Detection Rule**: If Aesthetic scores 80+ but Accessibility <70, you've hit this

### "Trend Overdose" 
**Symptom**: Recommending glassmorphism, bento grids, and neobrutalism together
**Diagnosis**: Treating trends as additive rather than selective
**Fix**: Pick max 1-2 trend elements that serve the content purpose
**Detection Rule**: If suggesting 3+ current trends simultaneously, stop and refocus

### "Hierarchy Blindness"
**Symptom**: All typography sizes within 2px of each other getting scored as "good hierarchy"
**Diagnosis**: Not testing 3-second scan path
**Fix**: Verify 1.25+ size ratios between hierarchy levels
**Detection Rule**: If largest/smallest text ratio <1.5x, hierarchy fails

### "Perfect Score Inflation"
**Symptom**: Giving 90+ scores to designs with obvious improvement opportunities
**Diagnosis**: Comparing against low standards instead of best-in-class
**Fix**: Compare against portfolio-worthy examples (Apple, Linear, Stripe)
**Detection Rule**: If giving 90+ without 3 specific excellence justifications, recalibrate

### "Generic Feedback Loop"
**Symptom**: Same improvement suggestions across different design contexts
**Diagnosis**: Not analyzing the specific visual scanning path and user intent
**Fix**: Trace actual eye movement and identify context-specific friction
**Detection Rule**: If using identical remix suggestions for different projects, personalize analysis

## Worked Examples

### Example 1: E-commerce Product Page Critique

**Initial Scores**: Overall 67/100
- Accessibility: 55 (failing contrast, tiny touch targets)
- Layout: 70 (functional grid, cramped spacing)  
- Typography: 80 (clear hierarchy, good fonts)
- Modernity: 65 (safe choices, no current trends)

**Decision Process**:
1. **Score <70** → Start with Accessibility
2. **Contrast check**: Price text #999 on #fff = 2.85:1 (FAIL)
3. **Touch targets**: "Add to Cart" button 36x28px (FAIL)
4. **Quick win identified**: Fix these basics first

**Expert vs Novice**:
- **Novice** would suggest trendy animations or glassmorphism overlay
- **Expert** catches that users can't even read the price clearly

**Remix Priority**:
1. **5min fix**: Change price to #767676 (4.54:1 contrast)
2. **5min fix**: Expand CTA to 44x44px minimum
3. **30min**: Add 8px spacing system for breathing room
4. **Later**: Consider subtle modern touches once fundamentals solid

### Example 2: SaaS Dashboard Conflicting Scores

**Initial Scores**: Overall 74/100
- Accessibility: 85 (excellent focus states, WCAG AA)
- Typography: 60 (weak hierarchy, font soup)
- Layout: 80 (clean grid, good whitespace)
- Modernity: 70 (contemporary but safe)

**Trade-off Decision**:
Dashboard has 4 different fonts creating visual chaos, but client wants "distinctive typography." Accessibility is solid, so focus on Typography dimension.

**Resolution Process**:
1. **Keep** the distinctive display font for headers only
2. **Consolidate** body text to single sans-serif
3. **Use weight/size** for hierarchy instead of font switching
4. **Result**: Maintains visual interest while gaining clarity

**Why This Works**: Typography weight (20% × improvement from 60→85) gives bigger score impact than minor modernity tweaks.

## Quality Gates

### Assessment Complete Checklist
- [ ] All 6 dimensions scored with specific evidence cited
- [ ] Overall weighted score calculated correctly (not just average)
- [ ] 3-second visual scan path described with entry point and flow
- [ ] At least one WCAG contrast check performed and documented
- [ ] Comparison made to best-in-class example in same category
- [ ] Top 3 strengths identified with specific supporting details
- [ ] Improvement opportunities ranked by effort/impact ratio
- [ ] Remix suggestions include implementation hints (CSS properties, spacing values)
- [ ] Trade-offs between dimensions explicitly acknowledged
- [ ] Score rationale would be defendable to original designer

### Scoring Accuracy Gates
- [ ] No dimension scores >90 without exceptional justification
- [ ] Accessibility score reflects actual WCAG testing, not assumptions
- [ ] Modernity assessment references specific 2024+ vs dated patterns
- [ ] Typography score accounts for line-length and hierarchy ratios
- [ ] Layout score includes whitespace distribution analysis

## NOT-FOR Boundaries

**Don't use design-critic for**:
- Writing actual CSS/HTML implementation → Use `frontend-developer`
- Pure accessibility audits without aesthetic assessment → Use `color-contrast-auditor`  
- Creating brand identity guidelines from scratch → Use `brand-strategist`
- Detailed user research or usability testing → Use `ux-researcher`
- Motion design and animation choreography → Use `motion-designer`
- Icon design or illustration creation → Use `visual-designer`
- Content strategy or copywriting review → Use `content-strategist`

**Delegate when**:
- Client asks "how do I code this?" → `frontend-developer`
- Request is "make this accessible" without design scoring → `color-contrast-auditor`
- Need involves user interviews or A/B testing → `ux-researcher`
Pliki w paczce (5)
  • CHANGELOG.md 1 KB
  • SKILL.md 7 KB
  • references/assessment-rubric.md 6 KB
  • references/remix-patterns.md 6 KB
  • references/trend-timeline.md 6 KB

Wersje

W bazie nie ma innych skilli o nazwie design-critic.

Migawka bazy z 13.11.2026 · wersja paczki 0b08cd116920 (skrót SHA-256 całej paczki)

Pobrania w ostatnich 30 dniach: 0 · ranking

Zgłoś problem z tym skillem: szkodliwa treść, błędny opis albo prośba autora o usunięcie.

Podobne skille

  • 90design-review
    Ocenia zmianę interfejsu pod kątem UX, jakości wizualnej i użycia systemu projektowego na podstawie zrzutów ekranu.
  • 100ios-design-review
    Ocenia jakość projektu UI i UX aplikacji iOS według zasad projektowych Apple i języka Liquid Glass z WWDC25 oraz WWDC26.
  • 90design-review
    Dostarcza listy kontrolne przeglądu projektu, standardy dostępności i wzorce UX do audytu interfejsu.
  • 100photo-composition-critic
    Krytykuje kompozycję zdjęć w oparciu o estetykę obliczeniową (AVA, NIMA, LAION-Aesthetics): ocena jakości, analiza kompozycji i punktacja estetyczna.
  • 100design-review
    Przeprowadza strukturalną krytykę projektu względem briefu i kodu: hierarchia wizualna, spójność, responsywność, dostępność i wierność estetyce.
  • 90proof-design
    Przeprowadza audyt jakości projektu graficznego: czerwone flagi, klasyfikacja wagi problemów i karta oceny jakości wizualnej przed premierą.

Uwagi i zgłoszenia

Wiadomość trafi do Bartosza Sokolińskiego. Adres e-mail jest potrzebny tylko do odpowiedzi. Szczegóły w polityce prywatności.