comparing-open-source-projects
/comparing-open-source-projects
Bada i porównuje darmowe projekty open source w danej dziedzinie: popularność, utrzymanie, licencje i dopasowanie, z raportem HTML.
- Autor
- aspiers ↗
- Repozytorium
- ai-config ↗
- Licencja
- GPL-3.0
- Ostatnia zmiana repozytorium
- 08.10.2026
Ocena i bezpieczeństwo
- Pliki w paczce
- 3
- Skrypty
- 0
- Komentarze HTML
- 0
- Adresy URL w SKILL.md
- 0
Brak sygnałów. Repozytorium zmienione 08.10.2026, bez odwołań do wycofanych modeli i API.
GPL-3.0, otwarta.
Co robi i kiedy
Bada i porównuje darmowe projekty open source w danej dziedzinie: popularność, utrzymanie, licencje i dopasowanie, z raportem HTML.
Oryginalny opis (EN)
Researches and compares free and open source software projects in a supplied domain, using either user-named candidates or a discovered shortlist. Use when evaluating FOSS alternatives, comparing GitHub popularity, maintenance, licences, domain fit, trade-offs, or producing a linked HTML comparison report.
Jak działa
- Establish the comparison set
- Collect comparable evidence
- Analyse and recommend
- Produce the report
Podgląd SKILL.md
--- name: comparing-open-source-projects description: >- Researches and compares free and open source software projects in a supplied domain, using either user-named candidates or a discovered shortlist. Use when evaluating FOSS alternatives, comparing GitHub popularity, maintenance, licences, domain fit, trade-offs, or producing a linked HTML comparison report. --- # Comparing Open Source Projects Compare projects against the user's actual domain and use case, not against a context-free feature checklist. Treat current popularity, maintenance, and licensing claims as evidence that must be checked rather than remembered. ## Establish the comparison set - When the user names exact candidates, compare those candidates. Do not add or replace projects unless the user also asks for discovery. - When the user supplies only a domain, define a transparent, representative shortlist from current research. Search across project websites, canonical forges, ecosystem directories, and credible roundups; then verify every candidate against primary sources. - State the inclusion criteria and important exclusions. Do not imply that a shortlist is exhaustive. - Ask one focused clarification when different interpretations of the domain would materially change the candidates or recommendation. Otherwise state reasonable assumptions in the report. - If a named candidate is source-available, proprietary, abandoned, or not a real match, retain it and explain the limitation rather than silently substituting another project. ## Collect comparable evidence Use the same observation date and activity window for every project. Prefer canonical project and repository sources; use secondary sources to discover claims, not to establish them. For every candidate, establish: 1. **Identity and fit:** canonical project and repository, relevant edition or component, supported use cases, deployment model, and important scope boundaries. 2. **GitHub popularity:** the star count of the canonical primary repository, with its repository link and an as-of UTC date. Do not sum an organisation, plugins, forks, or mirrors. If GitHub is not canonical, report `N/A` and identify any GitHub mirror separately. Stars measure attention, not quality. 3. **Maintenance:** archived or deprecation state, date of the latest default- branch commit, latest stable release, commit/release activity over a common window, and evidence of issue or pull-request responsiveness where useful. Distinguish active development, maintenance-only maturity, sporadic work, inactivity, and insufficient evidence. Do not infer maintenance from stars or from one recent automated commit. 4. **Licence:** exact licence name and SPDX identifier when one exists, linked to the governing licence text. Check multiple licences, exceptions, component-specific terms, and community-versus-enterprise boundaries. GitHub's detected licence is a discovery hint, not a substitute for reading the repository's licence files. Clearly distinguish OSI/FSF-recognised open source licences from source-available terms and avoid presenting the report as legal advice. 5. **Decision factors:** capabilities relevant to the requested domain, maturity, integrations, operational burden, documentation/community, major limitations, and the kinds of users for whom the project is or is not a good fit. Link factual claims to evidence. Use exact dates and counts where available, and mark unknowns instead of estimating. Explain the basis of qualitative maintenance ratings so a mature low-churn project is not automatically treated as abandoned. ## Analyse and recommend Normalise terminology and compare like with like. Separate observations from judgement, identify material evidence gaps, and explain trade-offs instead of manufacturing a universal winner. Base recommendations on the user's stated needs and call out when licensing or maintenance makes an otherwise strong candidate unsuitable. Use the mandatory high-level summary matrix for orientation. Add focused matrices for distinct facets when they make a dense comparison easier to understand. In matrices, apply accessible traffic-light ratings to cells where relative strength or suitability can be judged fairly; retain plain text and leave non-ordinal facts uncoloured. The reporting contract defines the rating semantics and multi-matrix structure. ## Produce the report Read [the HTML reporting contract](references/reporting.md) completely before writing the report. Use [the self-contained report template](assets/report-template.html) as the structural and visual basis. The finished report must be written under `docs/research/` in the current Git repository and opened with the repository-specific opener described in the reporting contract.
Pliki w paczce (3)
- SKILL.md 5 KB
- assets/report-template.html 15 KB
- references/reporting.md 8 KB
Wersje
W bazie nie ma innych skilli o nazwie comparing-open-source-projects.
Migawka bazy z 13.11.2026 · wersja paczki a701f741490e (skrót SHA-256 całej paczki)
Pobrania w ostatnich 30 dniach: 0 · ranking
Zgłoś problem z tym skillem: szkodliwa treść, błędny opis albo prośba autora o usunięcie.
Podobne skille
- 100assess-oss
Ocenia projekty open source na podstawie danych z GitHub, npm i crates.io: utrzymanie, popularność i licencje. - 90matrix-comparison
Porównuje alternatywy w rankingu HTML z osobnymi kryteriami, kolorowymi ocenami i filtrami, z linkami do źródeł. - 100contributing-to-major-open-source-projects
Wyjaśnia zasady wkładu w duże projekty open source, w tym CLA, DCO i zarządzanie, zanim zmiana trafi do repozytorium. - 100open-source-project-shortlisting
Buduje krótkie listy projektów open source według wymagań, z metadanych GitHub, wydań, współtwórców i dokumentacji przez Crawlora, porównując możliwości, utrzymanie, licencje i zgodność. - 95hot-pick
Znajduje w GitHubie popularne projekty open source pasujące do zadania, sprawdza ich możliwości i stosuje je do wykonania oraz weryfikacji wyniku. - 100github-repo-explore
Przeszukuje zewnętrzne repozytoria GitHub przez gh CLI, aby znaleźć wzorce i przykłady implementacji w projektach open source.