source-evaluation
/source-evaluation
Judge whether a source is credible and relevant: authority, evidence, bias, and recency. Use when deciding whether to trust and cite a source, in any research.
- Author
- Amey-Thakur ↗
- Repository
- AI-SKILLS ↗
- Licence
- MIT
- Last repository change
- 05.09.2026
Assessment and security
- Files in this package
- 1
- Scripts
- 0
- HTML comments
- 0
- URLs in SKILL.md
- 0
No signals detected. Repository changed on 05.09.2026, without references to retired models or APIs.
MIT, open: use and modify while retaining author attribution.
What it does and when to use it
Judge whether a source is credible and relevant: authority, evidence, bias, and recency. Use when deciding whether to trust and cite a source, in any research.
Original author description
Judge whether a source is credible and relevant: authority, evidence, bias, and recency. Use when deciding whether to trust and cite a source, in any research.
How it works
- Method
- Boundaries
SKILL.md preview
--- name: source-evaluation description: "Judge whether a source is credible and relevant: authority, evidence, bias, and recency. Use when deciding whether to trust and cite a source, in any research." --- # Source evaluation Not all sources deserve equal trust, and the credible-looking ones are often the trap. Source evaluation is the habit of asking, before you rely on anything, who is behind it, what backs their claim, what they want you to believe, and whether it is current, so your conclusions rest on solid ground. ## Method 1. **Identify the author and their authority.** Who produced this, and are they in a position to know? Expertise, credentials, and a track record in the specific domain matter; a confident stranger and a domain expert are not equal. Anonymous or unattributed claims start at low trust (see web-research's lateral reading to check them). 2. **Check the evidence behind the claim.** Does the source show its work (data, citations, methodology, primary references) or just assert? A claim with checkable evidence beats an eloquent one without. Follow the citations: a source citing strong primary evidence is stronger than one citing nothing or citing other opinions (see reading-papers, writing-with-evidence). 3. **Assess bias and motivation.** What does the source want, and how might that shape what they say? A vendor on their own product, an advocate for their cause, an outlet with a known slant: bias does not make a source wrong, but it tells you what to scrutinize and where to seek a counter-source. Follow the incentives (see mental-models' incentives). 4. **Weigh source type by the claim.** Peer-reviewed research and official primary data for facts; reputable journalism for events; practitioner accounts for real-world experience; forums and social media for leads, not conclusions. Match the source's authority to the weight of the claim you are hanging on it. 5. **Check recency and currency.** Is it current enough for a claim that changes over time (technology, prices, best practices, contested science)? An authoritative source from years ago can be authoritatively outdated. Note the date and whether newer work supersedes it. 6. **Prefer the primary and corroborated.** Trace claims to their origin rather than trusting the retelling (see web-research), and for important or contested claims, require independent corroboration (see fact-checking). A single source, however credible, is a single point of failure. ## Boundaries - Evaluation manages risk; it does not make any source certain. Even good sources err, so keep your confidence proportional to the evidence and flag uncertainty (see the honesty ethic throughout). - Credibility is domain-specific: a source authoritative on one topic is a layperson on another. Evaluate per claim, not by the source's general reputation. - Speed-versus-rigor scales with stakes: a low-stakes fact needs a quick check; a decision-shaping or public claim needs full evaluation and corroboration (see fact-checking).
Versions
| Repository | Score | Licence |
|---|---|---|
| This page · Amey-Thakur/AI-SKILLS | 90 | MIT |
| oborchers/fractional-cto | 100 | MIT |
Database snapshot: 13.11.2026 · package version 2ed2184817a7 (SHA-256 digest of the entire package)
Downloads in the last 30 days: 0 · ranking
Report a problem with this skill: harmful content, incorrect descriptions or an author’s removal request.
Similar skills
- 95BiasCheck
Three-layer bias analysis of any URL, file, or text: fetches the content and cited studies, then audits data bias, source conflicts, and journalism distortions. USE WHEN bias analysis, analyze bias, bias check, check this study, who funded this, is this source biased, fact-check… - 100source-credibility-assessment
Evaluates how much weight a source deserves before a claim from it is used. Applies SIFT lateral reading (Stop, Investigate the source, Find better coverage, Trace to the original), checks fitness with CRAAP criteria (currency, relevance, authority, accuracy, purpose), traces… - 100source-research
Fast topic research with source discovery, source quality evaluation, and concise synthesis. Use when looking up recent information, comparing sources, or producing a quick/detailed summary with citations. - 100research-methodology
Plan, conduct, evaluate, and synthesize rigorous research investigations with credible evidence and a traceable method, including source-to-claim closure for media evidence. Do not use this skill for repeated source extraction and durable note orchestration; use… - 95BiasCheck
Three-layer bias analysis on any URL, file, or text — auto-fetches the content and any cited study, then audits data-level biases, source conflicts of interest, and journalism-added distortions, separating what the data supports from what's editorialized. USE WHEN bias analysis,… - 100source-evaluation-bibliography
Evaluate source quality, build annotated bibliographies, and maintain curated reference collections. Covers the CRAAP test, source classification, citation management, and research documentation patterns. Triggers on source evaluation, bibliography creation, or research documentation requests.