Skip to content
Skills Library
Education · Learning & explanation

source-analysis

/source-analysis

Workflow W3: source-based reasoning and material questions. Decomposes the prompt, layers the source, matches the student's answer against scoring points, and rewrites it into scoring sentences. Also marks a student's finished answer like an exam. Use when a material question is pasted in, when an answer gets only half marks, or when someone asks how to stop copying the source.

Repository
czl-experts ↗
Licence
MIT
Last repository change
01.11.2026

Assessment and security

100/ 100Class: good
Format25 / 25
Frontmatter with name and description, valid name, description up to 1,024 characters, name matching the folder.
Discoverability25 / 25
Description explains when to use the skill, has a reasonable length and uses third person.
Content35 / 35
At least 150 words and at most 500 lines, headings, step lists, examples or code.
Hygiene15 / 15
No placeholders such as TODO, no Windows paths, with a licence.
Riskno signals detected in the scan
Files in this package
4
Scripts
0
HTML comments
0
URLs in SKILL.md
0
Deprecation

No signals detected. Repository changed on 01.11.2026, without references to retired models or APIs.

Licence

MIT, open: use and modify while retaining author attribution.

What it does and when to use it

Workflow W3: source-based reasoning and material questions. Decomposes the prompt, layers the source, matches the student's answer against scoring points, and rewrites it into scoring sentences. Also marks a student's finished answer like an exam. Use when a material question is pasted in, when an answer gets only half marks, or when someone asks how to stop copying the source.

Original author description

Workflow W3: source-based reasoning and material questions. Decomposes the prompt, layers the source, matches the student's answer against scoring points, and rewrites it into scoring sentences. Also marks a student's finished answer like an exam. Use when a material question is pasted in, when an answer gets only half marks, or when someone asks how to stop copying the source.

How it works

  1. 工作流契约
  2. 一、四步法:每一歩都能被检查
  3. 二、批改:按点给分,不按感觉给分
  4. 三、骨架答案怎么写(不代写)
  5. 四、史料价值题(单独一类,答法不同)
  6. 五、类型与可信度速判
  7. 六、一个完整的示例骨架
  8. 七、禁忌
Original SKILL.md headings · 144 lines, 446 words
SKILL.md preview
---
name: source-analysis
description: "Workflow W3: source-based reasoning and material questions. Decomposes the prompt, layers the source, matches the student's answer against scoring points, and rewrites it into scoring sentences. Also marks a student's finished answer like an exam. Use when a material question is pasted in, when an answer gets only half marks, or when someone asks how to stop copying the source."
version: 1.0.0
---

# W3 史料实证与材料题

## 工作流契约

| 项 | 内容 |
|---|---|
| **名称** | 史料实证与材料题(source-analysis) |
| **任务职责** | 把"读材料—写答案"这个黑箱拆成四步可检查的动作,并给出**逐点对照的分数归属**,让学生知道每一分是怎么拿到或丢掉的。 |
| **输入参数** | 必填:材料原文(或照片转写)、设问、孩子写的答案。可选:参考答案、分值、年级、这道题的得分。**缺孩子的答案时只能讲方法,不能批改。** |
| **执行步骤** | ① 拆设问:圈出"根据材料/结合所学""概括/分析/说明/评价""几问、各几分" → ② 分层:按句号、分号、转折词把材料切成 2—5 层,每层一句批注 → ③ 提取:每层抽出"谁—做了什么—结果" → ④ 转化:把提取结果换成学科术语(见 `references/term-bank.md`)→ ⑤ 对照:孩子的答案逐点判"有/半/无",给出得分归属 → ⑥ 改写:给一份"骨架式"答案(只给结构与关键词,不给完整成文) |
| **判断条件** | 设问含"根据材料"→ 答案必须有材料依据,纯用所学不得分;含"结合所学"→ 必须有材料之外的知识;含"概括"→ 不得照抄原文;含"分析"→ 必须有因果链;多问 → 分问作答,混在一起按一问给分;孩子答案全是原文摘抄 → 先停在这练"概括",不往下讲 |
| **输出格式** | ① 设问拆解表(问什么/限制词/分值/答几点)② 材料分层批注 ③ 得分对照表(点/孩子写的/判定/该改成什么)④ 骨架答案 ⑤ 一个同类小练 |
| **异常处理** | 材料是图片且看不清 → 请对方转写或只讲方法;孩子没写答案 → 转"示范+仿写"模式;参考答案与设问不匹配 → 以设问为准并说明;开放型设问("谈谈你的认识")→ 转 W4 的结构,但史实仍从材料取;材料涉及超出教材的争议内容 → 只讲可考查部分,其余说明超出范围 |
| **必要依赖** | `references/question-types.md`(设问类型与答题动词)、`references/term-bank.md`(术语替换表)、`references/marking-sheet.md`(批改表模板)、`materials/concepts.md` |

## 一、四步法:每一歩都能被检查

### 第 1 步 拆设问(最容易被跳过,也是提分最快的一步)

拿到题先不看材料,只看设问,填这张表:

| 要填 | 例 |
|---|---|
| 问几问 | 两问,别当一问答 |
| 每问几分 | 6 分 + 8 分,决定答几点 |
| 答案来源 | "根据材料"/"结合所学"/"综合上述材料" |
| 答题动词 | 概括/分析/说明/评价/比较/指出 |
| 限制词 | 时间("明清时期")、空间("西欧")、主体("政府") |

**学生 80% 的"答偏"发生在这一步,不是发生在理解材料。** 只答第一问、把"分析"写成"概括"、把"根据材料"答成"背教材",都是没拆设问。

### 第 2 步 分层

按标点与逻辑切,不按行切。

| 信号 | 怎么切 |
|---|---|
| 句号 | 一层一件事 |
| 分号 | 同一件事的两个方面 |
| "但""然而""不过" | 转折后是重点,常是命题落点 |
| "因此""故" | 结论层,往往是答案直接来源 |
| 引号内的原话 | 常是态度与立场的证据 |

层数控制在 2—5 层。切出 8 层说明切碎了,回到句号重切。

### 第 3 步 提取

每层只回答三个问题:**谁、做了什么、结果如何**。写在材料旁边,一句话一层。

不允许在这一步写"反映了""说明了"——那是第 4 步的事。提前评价会导致答案全是空词。

### 第 4 步 转化(术语化)

把口语换成本学科的说法。这一步决定"看着对但不得分"。

| 材料原话 | 转化后 |
|---|---|
| "官府不管了,让商人自己卖" | 政府放宽对商业的限制 |
| "读书人越来越多,考不上的人也多了" | 科举制发展,士人阶层扩大 |
| "机器一开,手工织布的都失业了" | 机器生产排挤手工业,传统手工业者破产 |
| "钱越来越不值钱" | 货币贬值,物价上涨 |

## 二、批改:按点给分,不按感觉给分

### 得分对照表(核心交付物)

| 应有点 | 孩子写的 | 判定 | 改成什么 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 材料层 1:政府放宽限制 | "政府支持商业" | 半 | 政府**放宽**对商业的限制("支持"过强,材料只说不管) |
| 材料层 2:商人地位上升 | 未答 | 无 | 商人社会地位有所提高,可与士人交往 |
| 结合所学:商品经济繁荣 | "经济很好" | 无 | 商品经济发展,白银货币化(术语缺失不计分) |

**判定标准只有三档:**
- **有**:术语准确 + 与设问方向一致 → 满分点。
- **半**:方向对但表述过强/过弱/缺术语 → 一半分,并说明差在哪。
- **无**:无此点,或与设问方向不符 → 0 分,说明该点应从材料哪一层来。

### 批改时的三个禁止

1. 不许只写"答案不完整"。要指出缺的是哪一层、哪一问。
2. 不许用"语言不够精炼"当评语。要给出可替换的术语。
3. 不许直接把参考答案贴上去当批改结果。参考答案是给老师看的,学生需要的是"我怎么写到那一句"。

## 三、骨架答案怎么写(不代写)

给结构,不给整段成文。格式如下:

```
(1)第一问(6 分,答 3 点)
① 材料层1关键词 → 术语:______
② 材料层2关键词 → 术语:______
③ 结合所学:______(写出制度名或事件名)
```

学生填完空,才算练过。直接给成文答案,他抄完下次还是不会。

## 四、史料价值题(单独一类,答法不同)

设问常是"上述材料对研究某问题有何价值"。**标准动作是两头都说。**

| 要说 | 句式 |
|---|---|
| 能证明什么 | 该材料属于__(类型),可用于研究__(问题),其中"__"一句可佐证__ |
| 不能证明什么 | 但该材料受__(作者立场/记录目的/时代局限)影响,不能单独用于说明__,需与__(其他类型史料)互证 |

只说前半句,最多拿一半分。这是史料实证题最稳定的失分点。

## 五、类型与可信度速判

| 史料类型 | 通常价值 | 通常局限 |
|---|---|---|
| 档案、诏令 | 制度与官方行为的直接证据 | 只记录官方视角,隐去执行偏差 |
| 私人日记、书信 | 心态、日常、私密决策 | 自我美化,样本单一 |
| 报刊 | 舆论与时代氛围 | 有政治立场与审查 |
| 器物、遗址 | 物质生活、技术水平 | 难以直接反映观念 |
| 统计图表 | 趋势与规模 | 口径可能被政治干预(如户籍统计) |
| 后人著述 | 系统解释 | 隔了时代,含作者建构 |

**判断口诀:** 先问"谁在什么位置上写的",再问"他为什么写",最后问"他没写什么"。第三问最难,也最能拿分。

## 六、一个完整的示例骨架

材料(节选,示意):
> "(明中期后)富室之称雄者,江南则推新安,江北则推山右。新安大贾,鱼盐为业……山右或盐、或丝、或转贩,其富甚于新安。"

设问:根据材料,概括明中期后商帮发展的特点。(6 分)

| 步 | 动作 |
|---|---|
| 拆设问 | 一问;6 分答 3 点;来源"根据材料";动词"概括";限制"明中期后" |
| 分层 | 层 1:富室以地域称雄(江南新安/江北山右);层 2:经营行业(鱼盐、丝、转贩);层 3:实力对比(山右富于新安) |
| 提取 | 按地域形成商人群体;经营大宗商品与长途贩运;不同商帮实力有差异 |
| 转化 | 出现地域性商人群体(商帮);以盐、丝等大宗商品和长途贩运为主;商帮间实力不均 |
| 骨架 | ① 地域性商帮形成 ② 经营大宗商品与长途贩运 ③ 商帮实力存在差异 |

三句话,18 个字左右,6 分到手。**概括题不需要长,需要的是"每点一个术语"。**

## 七、禁忌

- 不要把"读不懂材料"当成阅读能力问题。多数情况是没拆设问,读的时候不知道要找什么。
- 不要让学生背"答题模板句"。模板句在材料不匹配时是负分。
- 不要在批改里写"多练就好了"。要写"下次这道题先画三条横线"。
Files in this package (4)
  • SKILL.md 9 KB
  • references/marking-sheet.md 3 KB
  • references/question-types.md 3 KB
  • references/term-bank.md 3 KB

Versions

The database has no other skills named source-analysis.

Database snapshot: 13.11.2026 · package version db0de84b42f9 (SHA-256 digest of the entire package)

Downloads in the last 30 days: 0 · ranking

Report a problem with this skill: harmful content, incorrect descriptions or an author’s removal request.

Similar skills

  • 100diagnose-answer
    Diagnose one exam answer the student wrote - mark it like the examiner, say in plain words why each mark was lost, tag a mistake code only if one clearly fits, show the full-mark version in the subject's exact format, log it, cross-check other subjects, then push it into the…
  • 100exam-stack
    Turn a large pool of past written exams into a prioritized, interactive study page (an "exam stack"). It counts which question types recur across the papers, ranks them by points for the time they take, and gives each one a solving recipe, what graders give points for, and real…
  • 92mimir-past-questions
    Drill a course's real past-paper questions from the student's Mimir learning folder, ranked by marks and past-paper frequency - one real question per question type, answer key checked before it is shown. Use only when the student asks to practise or go through past questions,…
  • 100interview-builder
    Turn a source .md document into a complete, research-backed interview kit — conduct rules, a leveled question bank with a full answer key and scoring anchors, and an evaluation model. Use whenever the user wants to build, generate, or update interview questions, an assessment, a…
  • 100exam-forge
    Turns lecture-note PDFs into a printable question book whose questions come only from those sources and have passed an independent review (multiple choice, open-ended, fill-in-the-blank, true/false). Takes the job from a form in the local Studio, or from the chat. Use when the…
  • 100essay-argument
    Workflow W4: argumentative essays and open-ended questions. Turns a source or a claim into a defensible thesis, builds a two-to-three point structure with historical evidence, supplies a 12-point rubric and a self-check list, and marks a student's draft. Use when a student…

Feedback and reports

Your message goes to Bartosz Sokoliński. An email address is needed only for a reply. See the privacy policy.